Handcrafted Baked Goods Made Fresh Daily
Serving Rutherford and the surrounding Bergen County community with artisan breads, custom celebration cakes, and seasonal pastries since we opened our doors on Park Avenue.
Place Your Order TodayAbout
Varrelmann's Bake Shop has been a fixture on Park Avenue in Rutherford, New Jersey, bringing the aroma of freshly baked goods to the neighborhood. Our team of dedicated bakers starts work before dawn each morning, ensuring that every loaf, pastry, and treat that reaches our display cases is at its peak of freshness.
We believe in using quality ingredients and time-honored techniques to create baked goods that feel like they came from your own kitchen. From crusty artisan breads to delicate celebration cakes, each item receives the same attention to detail. If you are picking up a dozen cookies for an office meeting or ordering a custom wedding cake, we approach every order with the same care.
Our shop welcomes walk-in customers Thursday through Saturday, with extended hours until 6 PM, and Sunday mornings until 2 PM. We also take special orders ahead of time, so you can secure exactly what you need for your event or gathering.
Services
Artisan Breads
Crusty sourdough, soft sandwich loaves, and specialty breads baked fresh every morning for sandwiches, toast, and everything in between.
Custom Celebration Cakes
Birthday cakes, wedding cakes, and anniversary cakes decorated to match your vision. We work with you to design a cake that tastes as good as it looks.
Daily Pastries and Danish
Flaky croissants, fruit-filled Danish, and rotating seasonal pastries available Thursday through Sunday while supplies last.
Cookies and Bars
Classic chocolate chip cookies, oatmeal raisin, lemon bars, and brownie varieties packaged for sharing or kept all to yourself.
Special Order Items
Need something specific? We accept custom requests for corporate events, holiday platters, and private celebrations with advance notice.
Why Choose Us
- Baked fresh daily by a team that genuinely cares about every item that leaves our kitchen
- Custom cake design services where we work directly with you on flavors, sizes, and decorations
- Located right on Park Avenue in Rutherford with free parking nearby
- Consistently rated 4.5 stars by our community of loyal customers
FAQ
What days is the bakery open?
We are open Thursday, Friday, and Saturday from 6 AM to 6 PM, and Sunday from 6 AM to 2 PM. We are closed Monday through Wednesday.
Do I need to order custom cakes in advance?
Yes, we recommend placing custom cake orders at least one week ahead of time. This gives us enough lead time to schedule the design work and baking. Call us at (201) 939-0462 to discuss your needs.
Can I place an order for pickup?
Absolutely. You can call ahead to reserve specific items, and we will have them ready for you when you arrive at the shop.
Do you accommodate dietary restrictions?
We can discuss ingredient options when you place a custom order. For our regular daily items, please ask our staff about specific allergens or ingredients.
Is there parking near the bakery?
Yes, there is public parking available on Park Avenue and side streets near our location at 60 Park Ave in Rutherford.
Contact
Stop by to see what is fresh from the oven, or give us a call at (201) 939-0462 to place a special order.
- Phone:
- (201) 939-0462
- Address:
- 60 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070
Hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:Closed
- Wednesday:Closed
- Thursday:6 AM to 6 PM
- Friday:6 AM to 6 PM
- Saturday:6 AM to 6 PM
- Sunday:6 AM to 2 PM